Procurement Process Improvement: A Practical Guide
What is procurement process improvement?
Procurement process improvement means finding where your buying process loses time, money or control, fixing the cause, and checking that the fix worked. Continuous improvement means doing this again and again in small steps, rather than once in a large project.
Every procurement team has improvement projects. Few keep improving after the project ends. The difference is usually simple. Teams that keep improving measure the process every month, give each problem an owner, and fix causes rather than symptoms.
Short answer. Improve a procurement process in six steps:
- Pick one process and measure how it performs today
- Map how the process actually works, not how the policy says it works
- Find the waste and its root cause
- Test a fix on a small scale
- Check the result against your starting figure
- Make the fix the standard way of working, then move to the next problem
Key takeaways
| Topic | Key point |
|---|---|
| Start small | Fix one process at a time, starting with the one users complain about most |
| Measure first | Without a starting figure, nobody can say whether the change helped |
| Real process | Map what people actually do, including the workarounds |
| Root cause | Fix why the problem happens, not just the case in front of you |
| Measures | Every measure can be gamed. Track measures that balance each other |
| Suppliers | Many improvements need the supplier. Build this into the contract |
Where do procurement processes usually lose time and money?
Most problems show up in the same places. Use this table to find where to start.
| Problem | What you see | Common cause |
|---|---|---|
| Slow approvals | Requests wait days or weeks for a purchase order | Too many approval levels, and approvers who are not reminded |
| Unclear requests | Buyers go back to users for details again and again | No standard request form, or no catalogue for common items |
| Specifications change after quotes | Suppliers must quote again and the event restarts | The need was not agreed with the user before going to market |
| Buying outside contracts | Same item bought at different prices from different suppliers | Contracts are hard to find, or the contract supplier is slow |
| Invoice mismatches | Invoices held because price or quantity differs from the order | Wrong price on the purchase order, or goods receipt not recorded |
| Slow supplier onboarding | A chosen supplier cannot be paid for weeks | Documents collected by email, and checks done one after another |
| Contracts renewing at old prices | Prices stay the same even when the market falls | No list of contract end dates and no owner for renewals |
| Repeat quotes for the same item | Buyers ask for quotes for the same item every month | No rate contract for regular items |
What does waste look like in procurement?
Lean thinking groups waste into seven types, first described by Taiichi Ohno at Toyota for factories (Lean Enterprise Institute). Each type has a procurement version.
| Type of waste | In a factory | In procurement |
|---|---|---|
| Waiting | Parts wait for the next machine | Requests wait for approval, and suppliers wait for answers to their questions |
| Over-processing | More work than the customer needs | Three quotes for a very small purchase, or a full tender for a low-risk item |
| Defects | Faulty parts that must be reworked | Wrong prices on purchase orders, which lead to invoice disputes |
| Transport | Moving parts around without need | Documents sent back and forth by email between people and systems |
| Motion | Workers searching for tools | Buyers searching for the latest contract or supplier contact |
| Inventory | Stock piling up between steps | Requests piling up in a buyer’s inbox, or excess stock from bulk buys |
| Overproduction | Making more than is needed | Reports produced every month that nobody reads |
Many teams add an eighth waste: unused skills. In procurement, this is an experienced buyer spending most of the day keying in purchase orders instead of working on sourcing.
How do you improve a procurement process, step by step?
These steps follow the Plan-Do-Check-Act cycle, a standard method for continuous improvement (ASQ).
1. Pick one process and measure it
Choose one process, such as “request to purchase order for indirect items”. Pick the one that users complain about most, or the one that costs the most. Then measure how it performs today. For example: the average number of days from request to purchase order, and how many requests are sent back for more detail.
Measure from the user’s point of view. The user does not care how long the buyer took. The user cares how long it took from asking to receiving.
2. Map how the process actually works
Draw each step, who does it, and how long it waits before the next step. Talk to the people who do the work, not only the managers. You will find steps that the policy does not mention, such as “the plant head checks every request by phone before approving”. These hidden steps are often where the time goes.
3. Find the waste and its root cause
Mark each step as useful or wasteful. For each wasteful step, ask “why?” until you reach a cause you can fix. For example:
- Invoices are held. Why? The invoice price differs from the purchase order.
- Why? The purchase order used an old price.
- Why? The buyer copied the last order instead of using the contract price.
- Why? Contract prices are kept in a spreadsheet that buyers cannot easily find.
The fix is to put contract prices where buyers raise orders. Telling accounts to “check invoices more carefully” would treat the symptom, not the cause.
4. Test a fix on a small scale
Try the fix on one site, one category or one buyer team first. This shows problems early and costs little if the fix does not work. Agree in advance what result would count as success.
5. Check the result
Compare the new figures with your starting figures. Look at the measures that could get worse as well. A shorter request-to-order time is not a gain if buyers achieved it by skipping competition.
6. Make it the standard, then move on
If the fix works, write it into the process, train people, and update the system. If it does not work, find out why and try a different fix. Then pick the next problem. This is what makes the improvement continuous.
What should you measure?
Pick a few measures that balance each other. Any single measure can be improved in a way that hurts the business.
| Measure | What it tells you | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Days from request to purchase order | How fast users get what they need | Buyers skipping competition to go faster |
| Share of spend under contract | How much buying happens at agreed prices | Contracts with high prices still count as “under contract” |
| Invoices matched first time | How accurate orders, receipts and invoices are | Matching rules loosened so more invoices pass |
| Quotes received per sourcing event | How much competition you are creating | Inviting suppliers who cannot really supply |
| Savings confirmed by finance | Whether lower prices reach the budget | Savings counted against an inflated first quote |
| Supplier on-time delivery | Whether suppliers meet their promises | Delivery dates moved after the order to look on time |
Agree with finance how savings are counted before you start. A saving measured against the supplier’s first quote, rather than the last price paid, can look large and mean little. For more, see our guide to procurement analytics.
How can contracts encourage suppliers to keep improving?
Many procurement costs sit with the supplier, so many improvements need the supplier’s help. A contract that only fixes the price for three years gives the supplier no reason to improve. Build improvement into the contract instead:
- A short list of measures. Agree four to six measures, such as on-time delivery, quality and response time. Review them with the supplier at fixed intervals. Our guide to supplier performance management covers how to set these up.
- A yearly improvement plan. Ask the supplier to propose improvements each year, such as a cheaper material, better packing or fewer deliveries. Review progress in the same meetings.
- Shared savings. When the supplier’s idea saves you money, share part of the saving with the supplier for an agreed period. If you take the whole saving, the ideas stop.
- Open-book costing for services. For agency and service contracts, ask the supplier to show the main parts of its cost, such as staff, overheads and margin. This shows where savings can come from without cutting the supplier’s margin below a fair level.
- Price reviews linked to the market. For long contracts, agree when and how the price will be reviewed, for example against a published index. This avoids paying old prices after the market has fallen.
Be careful with fixed yearly price cuts that are not linked to any real change. The supplier may meet them by cutting quality or service, and you will not see it until something goes wrong. For deeper work with key suppliers, see supplier development and supplier relationship management.
Kaizen, Lean or Six Sigma: which should you use?
| Method | What it means | Good for in procurement |
|---|---|---|
| Kaizen | Many small improvements made by the people who do the work | Daily problems, such as a confusing request form |
| Lean | Remove steps that add no value | Slow processes, such as approvals and supplier onboarding |
| Six Sigma | Use data to reduce errors and variation | Repeated errors, such as invoice mismatches |
| Plan-Do-Check-Act | Plan a change, test it, check the result, then adopt or adjust | Any improvement, as the basic cycle |
You do not need to choose one. Most procurement teams use the Plan-Do-Check-Act cycle as the base, Lean to remove waiting and extra steps, and Six Sigma tools only for repeated errors with good data behind them.
What are the common mistakes?
- Starting without a starting figure. Nobody can show the change, and support fades.
- Mapping the process from the policy. The real process, with its workarounds, is where the problems are.
- Fixing symptoms. Checking invoices harder does not fix wrong prices on purchase orders.
- Buying software first. A slow process put into new software is still slow. Fix the process, then automate it.
- Chasing one measure. Faster ordering at the cost of competition is not an improvement.
- Leaving suppliers out. Many of the largest gains need the supplier to change something.
- No owner after the project. Without someone checking the measures each month, the process slowly goes back to how it was.
How does Krinati support procurement process improvement?
Krinati’s eSourcing platform puts RFIs, RFQs, RFPs and reverse auctions in one place, in place of email. Suppliers bid online, and every invitation, bid and award decision is recorded. This removes much of the waiting and back-and-forth in sourcing, and gives you the data to measure competition and price trends. For the steps after sourcing, see our guide to eProcurement.
Frequently asked questions about procurement process improvement
What is procurement process improvement?
Procurement process improvement means finding where your buying process loses time, money or control, fixing the cause, and checking that the fix worked. Continuous improvement means doing this again and again in small steps, rather than once in a large project.
How do you improve the procurement process?
Pick one process and measure how it performs today. Map how it actually works. Find the waste and its root cause. Test a fix on a small scale. Check the result against your starting figure. If it worked, make it the standard way of working, then move to the next problem.
What are the most common problems in procurement processes?
Slow approvals, unclear purchase requests, specifications that change after suppliers have quoted, buying outside contracts, invoices that do not match the purchase order, slow supplier onboarding and contracts that renew automatically at old prices.
What measures should you track for procurement process improvement?
Track time from request to purchase order, the share of spend under contract, invoices that match the order first time, the number of quotes received per sourcing event, savings confirmed by finance and supplier on-time delivery. Track each measure from the start, so you can show the change.
How can contracts encourage suppliers to keep improving?
Agree a small set of performance measures and review them with the supplier at fixed intervals. Ask for a yearly improvement plan. Share the savings from ideas the supplier brings, so the supplier gains too. For service contracts, an open-book cost model makes it easier to see where savings can come from.
What is the difference between Kaizen, Lean and Six Sigma in procurement?
Kaizen means many small improvements made by the people who do the work. Lean focuses on removing steps that add no value, such as waiting for approvals. Six Sigma uses data to reduce errors and variation, such as invoice mismatches. Most procurement teams use ideas from all three.